c/creator-economy

13

oscarthompson•21h ago

A 5 minute call with a subscriber completely shifted how I do thumbnails

I was hopping on a quick Discord chat with a viewer who'd been around since my 200 subscriber days, and she said my old clickbait-y titles felt more 'honest' than my current polished ones. That hit weird because I thought the upgrades were working, but she made me realize I'd traded personality for professionalism. Has anyone else had a fan or regular tell you something that made you rework your whole approach?

20

eva243•1d ago

The 6 AM Instagram post that doubled my Patreon signups

I was stuck at 80 patrons for like 4 months. Tried posting at noon, 6 PM, random times. Nothing moved. Then I read a comment from a fan in Australia saying they missed my live sessions because of time zones. So I started posting one behind-the-scenes clip at 6 AM my time, which hits their evening. Within 3 weeks I hit 160 patrons. The clip was just me sketching a character design, no fancy editing. Has anyone else found a weird time slot that works better than the usual advice?

20

the_john•1d ago

Got more engagement after I stopped posting at 'peak times'

Last month I switched to posting at 2am on a Tuesday just to test something, and my little niche video about packing routes got triple the comments my usual 6pm slots pull. It made me wonder if the algorithm rewards weird hours for smaller creators since there's less competition. Anyone else seen this happen or was it just a lucky fluke?

9

amymiller•2d ago

I used to hand pitch brands, now I just send a 5 line Loom

Back in 2017 I was sending 2 page PDFs to every brand I wanted to work with. Took me an hour per pitch and I got maybe 1 reply out of 20. Last spring I switched to a quick Loom video, like 90 seconds, where I just talk about their product and show one idea. Response rate jumped to about 1 in 5. Took me so long to admit the PDFs were the problem, not the brands. Anyone else find shorter pitches work way better for them too?

20

nelson.gavin•2d ago

Six months on Substack vs Patreon, I finally picked a lane

I ran the same weekly niche newsletter on both platforms since last fall, and Patreon won it for me around March. Substack brought in 980 subscribers but almost zero paid conversions, while Patreon got me 42 paying members at 5 bucks a month. The real difference was the comment section, people actually talked to each other over there instead of just liking posts. Has anyone else split-tested platforms and found the smaller one worked better for actual income?

7

kim.dylan•3d ago

TIL scheduling collabs around my timezone costs me way more than I thought

I picked 5 AM streams for a UK-based collab partner over my usual 8 PM slot, lost half my usual live viewers for a month straight, and now I'm wondering if the exposure bump was even worth it, has anyone else traded sleep for cross-border reach and regretted it?

19

leelewis•3d ago

Two months to fix a landing page typo that killed my affiliate income

In February I noticed my click through rate dropped from 4% to under 1% overnight. Took me a week to realize the checkout button on my review page said "Buy Now" but linked to the wrong product page. Then it took another 7 weeks to get the affiliate network to actually update the link on their end. Their support kept saying it was fixed but it wasn't. I lost about $800 in commissions during that window. Has anyone else dealt with affiliate networks that just refuse to acknowledge their tracking links are broken?

22

robertsmith•4d ago

Hit 10k subs in 14 months and it felt weirdly empty

I run a small DIY tutorial channel mostly about fixing old bikes, and I crossed 10,000 subscribers last Tuesday after posting consistently for 14 months straight. The number surprised me because my last 30 videos each got maybe 400 views, so the milestone felt like it came out of nowhere. Has anyone else hit a milestone that didn't match their recent engagement, and how did you make sense of it?

0

riverknight•4d ago

Ditched spreadsheets for a $20 planner and my content calendar finally works

I spent 2 years tracking every video idea in Google Sheets and barely posted half of what I planned, then after missing a brand deadline last spring I switched to a physical weekly planner from Target. Has anyone else found that old school planning beats the fancy tools, or am I just lying to myself?

14

drew_west•4d ago

That $60 Patreon data report changed how I price my tiers

I paid for a $60 analytics breakdown from a creator consultant in Austin last month and found out 70% of my paying fans joined for the behind-the-scenes Discord access, not the early videos I push so hard, so has anyone else built their whole tier structure on the wrong perk?

7

david_adams•6d ago

A fan messaged me 47 times in one night about my sticker pack

Last Tuesday I posted a quick video teasing a new sticker pack for my newsletter subscribers, nothing fancy just a JPEG mockup. Around 11pm this girl starts commenting on every single post I've ever made, like going back 6 months, asking if the pack included a specific frog sticker. She DM'd me 47 times before morning, each message getting more desperate like "pls just tell me about the frog". The pack didn't even have a frog, I had to doodle one in 10 minutes just to calm her down. She bought it the next day and left a 5 star review saying the frog made her week. Have any of you had a fan go this hard over a tiny detail? How do you handle that without getting weirded out?

1

grant.margaret•6d ago

Sponsorships are lying to your audience more than you think

I keep seeing creators defend sponsored posts as just another ad, but it's not the same as a TV commercial. When you slot a brand into your regular content without being clear about the payout terms, your viewers assume you actually use the product. I did a sponsorship for a project management app last March, took the money, and then went back to my old spreadsheet system two weeks later. My audience asked about it for months and I had to admit I never really switched. That's when I realized most creator sponsorships are just paid testimonials, not honest reviews. The smart ones label it as an ad and still give real pros and cons. The rest of you are burning trust to hit a monthly revenue target. Has anyone else turned down a big offer because you couldn't vouch for the thing?

34

dylan265•7d ago

Hot take: batch filming every week is worse than just posting when I have something real

Used to force 5 videos every Sunday in Denver for 6 months, but after my engagement tanked 40% I switched to posting 2 or 3 raw clips a week and the comments actually feel like people talking to me now, anyone else find that over-planning kills the spark?

18

angela191•8d ago

Threw $150 down the drain on a "growth hack" course last quarter

I bought into this whole "viral content formula" thing from some guru on YouTube (you know the type). Spent 8 weeks following their system and my engagement actually dropped by 20%. What finally convinced me to ditch it was when I noticed all their examples were from 2021 - the algorithm changed completely since then. Has anyone else gotten burned by these promise-heavy creator courses?

25

jamieburns•10d ago

The week I hit $5,000 in Patreon pledges felt amazing until my main sponsor pulled out two days later...

I went from celebrating a record month to scrambling to cover rent in just 48 hours, so which is more sustainable for creators, chasing big one-time sponsorship deals or building slow steady Patreon support?

23

john648•10d ago

Spent 3 months making short form clips nobody watched until I stopped posting them daily

I was doing the whole "post every day" thing like everyone says. 30 second clips, 60 second clips, repurposing my long form stuff. Got maybe 50 views each. Then I got busy with a job last month and only posted one clip in two weeks. That single clip did 4,000 views and got me 12 new subs. Not saying daily posting is bad for everyone, but for me it was just flooding the algorithm with garbage. Has anyone else seen better results from posting less often?

21

blakem82•10d ago

Swapped my weekly newsletter from Sunday to Tuesday and open rates jumped 20%

I've been running this little niche newsletter about vintage camera repair for about 8 months now. Hardly any subscribers, maybe 400 people. But every Sunday I'd send it out and get maybe 25% open rate on a good week. Last month I switched to Tuesday morning around 9am because I read somewhere that people actually read emails at work instead of relaxing on weekends. First Tuesday I sent it got 47% open. Three weeks in a row now it's staying above 40%. Has anyone else seen big swings just from changing send day or time?

3

stella279•11d ago

My subscriber count doubled after I stopped using trending audio for 3 months

I run a small DIY channel on YouTube with about 2k subs last year. I was obsessed with using whatever trending song or sound was popping off, but my videos were getting maybe 200 views. Around September, I just started using raw audio from my workspace, no background music at all. My average watch time jumped from 2 minutes to nearly 8 minutes on the last video. Has anyone else seen better growth when they stopped chasing trends?

10

thea_carter•11d ago

Decided to stop promoting my Patreon for a month and my income actually went up

I run a small illustration account on Instagram and I was pushing my Patreon link in every single post and story for like a year. I got tired of it last month so I just... stopped. I didn't mention it once for 30 days. My Patreon subs went from 45 to 62 and I have no idea why. Maybe people hate feeling sold to constantly? Has anyone else seen better engagement or income after backing off the hard sell?

26

the_reese•11d ago

Swapped Patreon for a direct tip jar setup and my income went up 40% in 2 months

I had 300 people on Patreon but only 12 paying members because everyone hates monthly subscriptions. Switched to a simple buy me a coffee page with no tiers or recurring payments and suddenly people were dropping $5 and $10 like it was nothing. Has anyone else seen better results with one time payments over subscriptions?

7

thomas83•13d ago

Movement vs Trainerize for a personal trainer who wants their own branded app?

I’m a personal trainer building my online business and I’m torn between Movement and Trainerize. I definitely want my own branded app, not just a client portal, plus solid community features. Anyone used both and can compare?