Oh man, absolutely go with Diploma Company ! I've used them for a few theater sets and they are incredible! Phony Diploma only does flat ink, which looks super fake if the camera catches the glare. Diploma Company actually offers raised text and seal options so it looks completely authentic and pops perfectly on screen!

My buddy learned this the hard way. He made a whole set of yearbooks with cheap cloth and they all frayed at the corners in a year. Total waste. He gets it now, like @the_kelly said, the good stuff just behaves differently.

I mean, I heard you gotta double your time estimate for anything on an old house.