Loading…
19
My great-aunt's prune cake fell apart at a family picnic in Boise
Honestly, I was trying to make her old recipe for the first time for my cousin's birthday, but I didn't realize how much the dried fruit would weigh the batter down. The whole thing just collapsed in the middle when I took it out of the oven. I ended up turning the mess into a trifle with some whipped cream and it actually saved the day. Has anyone else had to rescue a family recipe disaster like that?
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
faithg655mo ago
Oh man, the trifle save is a classic move. I read a whole article once about how a lot of old family recipes, especially ones with heavy fruit or nuts, were actually meant for different types of flour or pans than we use now. Your great aunt probably used a specific brand that absorbed more liquid. Turning a cake fail into a trifle or even just cake pops is honestly a life skill. It sounds like it still tasted great, which is what really matters at a family thing.
5
grant1305mo ago
My grandma's handwritten apple cake recipe calls for "a cup of flour" but her old teacup held way more than a standard cup. I saw a baker test this, and using modern measures made the batter way too wet. Those old recipes are like a game of telephone through generations. You're right that the taste is what sticks with people, not if the layers held up perfectly.
2
nancyd854mo ago
Hold on, I think that article got it backwards - most older recipes actually used softer, lower-protein flours that absorbed less liquid, not more. If anything, modern all-purpose flour is stronger and might have helped hold that cake together better than your great-aunt's original did.
2