My great-grandma's cameo brooch just fell apart in my hands

I was getting it out of its box to wear for a family dinner yesterday, and the whole pin back just snapped off. It's been passed down since the 1890s, so I guess the metal just gave up. I'm kind of heartbroken, honestly. I've taken it to a jeweler in town who says they can fix it, but it'll cost about $150 and they have to replace the whole clasp. Has anyone else had to repair a really delicate old piece of jewelry? I'm nervous about changing any original parts.

3 comments

Log in to join the discussion

Log In

3 Comments

chen.jade6mo ago

Eh, it's just a clasp...

6

sean_martin444mo ago

Had a vintage watch with a clasp that kept popping open. Spent $120 on a new one from a local repair guy. Worth every penny. The old clasp was worn down from decades of use. A new clasp keeps the whole piece working right without messing up the original look. Made it functional again.

3

sandra2036mo ago

Oh man, that's so sad, I totally get why you're heartbroken. I used to be super against changing any original part on old family stuff, like it was a crime. But my view totally shifted after my mom's locket broke. A good jeweler fixed it so it could actually be worn again without fear, and honestly, seeing it used feels way more respectful than keeping it broken in a box forever. That repair cost sounds pretty normal for making it safe to wear, and a new clasp means you can actually enjoy it without worrying it'll fall apart.

5