L
18

Unpopular opinion: quenching a 5160 spring steel knife in water is a bad idea, even for a small blade.

I was at my home forge in Spokane last fall, finishing a 6-inch skinner from a 5160 truck leaf spring. I got impatient and dunked it straight into a bucket of water instead of my usual oil. It cracked with a sound like a gunshot, splitting right down the middle of the tang. I had to grind the whole thing back and start the heat treat over from scratch. Has anyone else had a quench go wrong because they rushed it?
2 comments

Log in to join the discussion

Log In
2 Comments
leelewis
leelewis1mo ago
Ask jordan184 what oil he uses now.
8
jordan184
jordan1841mo ago
Been there... ruined a good blade the same way.
1