Warning: my club spent 40 minutes arguing about whether a character lied, and the answer was on page 12
We met at a diner in Boise on Tuesday and half the group got stuck on whether the narrator was telling the truth about the boat. I flipped back and read the line out loud where she flat out admits it, and the guy who was loudest just goes "well, that's her word." Then it turned into a fight about trusting narrators in general, which somehow ate 40 more minutes. Does your group keep fighting about stuff that's right there in the text, or is mine just special?