Warning: dropped $70 on a home C-41 kit and the colors came out muddy on roll 1
I picked up a $70 two-bath C-41 kit at the camera store in Sacramento two months back, thinking I'd save money over lab prices, and my first roll of Portra came out muddy with green shadows because I couldn't keep the tank at 102 degrees steady. So here's the debate: some folks swear home color developing is worth the fuss and others say just mail it to a lab and keep your sanity, which side lands for you? Tell me if a cheap temp bath setup actually got your colors right or if you gave up and went back to paying $12 a roll at the lab.
70 bucks and two months later the green shadows are basically the kit flipping you off for trusting it. Look, a cheap temp bath setup is doable if you treat it like a science project: big plastic tub, hottest tap water you can get, and a thermometer you actually check every 30 seconds, not once at the start. But 102 degrees is no joke, a half degree drift over six minutes and your colors wander off. I ran a water bath for a year and got decent rolls maybe 70 percent of the time, and the other 30 percent made me want to throw the tank across the yard. If you shoot a lot of Portra and want repeatable results, mailing it out at 12 bucks a roll starts looking like a bargain real quick. Keep the kit for messing around on cheap film, but don't let it eat your good shots while you learn.