Rant: blew $40 on a screenwriting book that gave me a way better ending for Heat and now I can't rewatch it
I paid about 40 bucks for this old book on how to structure a third act, mostly out of boredom, and it spent a whole chapter on what it calls the "quiet cost" ending where the hero wins but loses the thing he actually wanted. That got me thinking about Heat, where McCauley should have just walked away from the bank job when he saw the cops, and the movie ends with him on a boat in Fiji with no money and no one, which is way sadder than him dying in a runway shootout. Does a quiet loss like that hit harder for you than a big death scene, or does it just feel like the writers got scared and went soft?
Ha, forty bucks to have a movie you love ruined for you, that is a great deal. But honestly the boat in Fiji thing is kind of genius, because dying in a shootout is almost a cop out when you think about it. A guy who planned every move sitting alone with nothing left hits way harder than a body on a runway.