I used to think library rebinding was a hack, then I paged through a 1911 ledger at the Ohio History Center
I have been a snob about keeping original bindings my whole time at this. Saw a traveling exhibit up in Columbus and they had a county ledger from 1911 that somebody had rebound in the 70s. Full cloth case, new endpapers, the works.
What got me was a note tucked in the back from the guy who did it. He left the original boards and spine strip inside a pocket so you could still see how it was put together. Lost 30 minutes just looking at that.
So now I'm rethinking my own rule. Anyone here ever do a conservation style rebind like that and keep the old boards? How do you mount them so they don't flop around?