Am I the only one who thinks pushing expired film two stops is a gamble, not a skill?
Shot a roll of film from a garage sale in Dayton that expired in 2009. Half the people on here told me to rate it at 400 and push it, said you get that grainy look everyone loves. The other half told me to shoot it at box speed and pray.
I split the roll. Pushed half, shot the other half normal. The pushed shots came out muddy brown with grain the size of gravel. The normal ones were flat but at least you could see faces. Not one shot from that roll was worth keeping. Wasted 36 frames and $14 on processing at the lab off Fifth Street.
So which camp are you in? Do you push old film and deal with the mess, or shoot it slow and take the flat look? I want to know if I just picked a bad roll or if pushing expired stock is mostly luck.