My HP5 negatives came out flat and gray until I changed one thing in my dev tank
I was developing HP5 at 68 degrees for 7 minutes with Ilfosol 3 and getting muddy, lifeless negatives for about 4 rolls in a row. I checked my thermometer against a second one and found it was reading 3 degrees high, so my developer was actually at 65 and never fully woke up. Once I fixed the temp and bumped agitation to the first 30 seconds then 5 seconds every minute, the same film gave me punchy blacks and actual contrast. I shot the same scene in my backyard in Portland before and after, and it looks like two different films. Anyone else run into a lying thermometer, and do you trust the cheap ones or spring for a dial?
Three degrees off sounds like a lot but I have to ask, did you actually test this with more than one roll? Because 65 vs 68 for 7 minutes is a small push, and HP5 is pretty forgiving. I have messed up temps worse than that and still got usable negs, just thinner. Also the agitation change alone could explain the contrast boost, so its hard to say the thermometer was the whole story. Cheap dials can lie but so can the room temp, your pour speed, and how long you wait before the stop bath.